1- Researcher: Huwayzi Aiyed Alsuwaidan
2- Researcher: Jibril Zein Jibril Al-Zubaidi
3- Researcher: Abdulrhmain Khalid Alanter
4- Researcher: Ahmed Ibrahim Mftah Ageeli
5- Researcher: Fahad Ali Rashed Alghamdi
6- Researcher: Ismail Saeed Shobili
7- Researcher: Saeed Mohammed Alghamdi
8- Researcher: Abdullah Muntaha Hassan Al-Maashi
Saudi Red Crescent Authority -Saudi Arabia
Background: Paramedics work in a continuous emergency care environment that combines rapid clinical decision-making, physical demands, ambulance driving, communication, and exposure to unpredictable events. Night work, rotating schedules, extended shifts, and limited recovery between duties can disturb sleep and contribute to occupational fatigue. These effects are relevant because reduced alertness, concentration, and judgment may influence both clinical performance and safety.
Objective: To systematically synthesize evidence published from 2012 to 2024 on the relationship between shift work, occupational fatigue, clinical performance, and patient or occupational safety among paramedics and operational emergency medical services (EMS) personnel.
Methods: A systematic search was conducted for studies published between January 2012 and December 2024. PubMed, including MEDLINE-indexed records, and PubMed Central (PMC) were the primary bibliographic sources, supplemented by targeted searches of publisher websites, journal archives, and backward reference-list screening. Eligible studies involved paramedics, emergency medical technicians, or operational EMS clinicians and examined shift schedules, sleep, fatigue, recovery, clinical performance, errors, adverse events, occupational injuries, safety-compromising behaviors, or fatigue-management interventions. Fourteen primary studies met the eligibility criteria. Methodological quality was appraised using design-specific Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) critical appraisal guidance, and findings were synthesized narratively because of substantial methodological and clinical heterogeneity.
Results: The 14 included studies showed that fatigue and disturbed sleep are common in EMS, particularly with rotating work, overnight duty, extended shifts, and insufficient recovery. Fatigued clinicians were more likely to report occupational injuries, medical errors or adverse events, and safety-compromising behaviors. Large observational evidence linked very long shifts with greater injury risk, while simulation research demonstrated reduced clinical decision accuracy across a night shift. However, not all 24-hour schedules produced measurable cognitive decline; findings indicated that workload and the opportunity to sleep during duty modify the effect of shift duration. Recovery between shifts and sleep regularity were also important determinants of fatigue. A cluster-randomized fatigue-education trial showed limited overall effects, suggesting that education alone is unlikely to address the problem.
Conclusion: Shift work contributes to occupational fatigue among paramedics, and fatigue is associated with clinically important safety outcomes. Risk is not determined by shift length alone. Workload, circadian timing, sleep opportunity, recovery between duties, and organizational scheduling practices interact to shape fatigue. EMS organizations should therefore manage fatigue as an operational and patient-safety risk through scheduling, adequate recovery time, opportunities for rest, monitoring of excessive workload, and supportive fatigue-management practices.
الكلمات المفتاحية
paramedics; emergency medical services; shift work; occupational fatigue; sleep; clinical performance; patient safety; medical errors; night shift,الصفحات: 782 -797